Skip to main content

Travel Guide

Italy

Florence, Pisa or Siena: choosing a Tuscan base

Florence, Pisa and Siena are three separate Tuscan towns, each with its own World Heritage listing and its own set of sites. This guide compares what is actually in each town, so a base can be chosen by the sites that matter rather than by the region's name.

On this page

Quick answer

Choose the town whose sites you most want to spend time in. Florence's historic centre was inscribed by UNESCO in 1982, according to Tuscany's tourism site, and the city is home to the Uffizi, Palazzo Pitti and the Boboli Gardens. Pisa's listed monuments stand together in one square, the Piazza del Duomo, also called Piazza dei Miracoli, with its cathedral, baptistery, Camposanto and leaning bell tower. Siena's listed site is its whole historic centre, and Tuscany's tourism site names the Piazza del Campo first among its places to visit. Each site is in its own town: a visit to Pisa planned from Florence still takes place in Pisa. XTOUR gives no travel times between them.

The short answer

Base yourself in the town whose sites you most want to spend unhurried time with. Florence, Pisa and Siena are three towns, each with its own World Heritage listing, and Tuscany's regional tourism site lists them as separate entries.[1] What is in each one differs more than the shared region suggests.

The three listings are different in kind. Tuscany's tourism site names several separate Florence buildings as examples of its historic centre, Pisa's listed monuments stand together in one square, and Siena's listing is its whole medieval centre.[1] XTOUR has no routing provider, so it does not say how long the journeys between them take or whether any pair fits in a day.

What is in Florence

Florence's historic centre was inscribed as a World Heritage site on 17 December 1982, according to Tuscany's regional tourism site, which gives the Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore, the Basilica of Santa Croce, the Uffizi Gallery and the Abbey of San Miniato al Monte as examples of the city's heritage.[1] The Uffizi Gallery is one of three sites run by the Gallerie degli Uffizi, with Palazzo Pitti and the Boboli Gardens.[2] The Uffizi, Pitti and Boboli guide explains how those three differ.

XTOUR's reading is that Florence suits a stay built around several separate visits, to its churches and to the three sites of the Uffizi institution among them.

What is in Pisa

Pisa's World Heritage site is the Piazza del Duomo, inscribed by the World Heritage Committee in 1987.[3] Tuscany's tourism site calls it the Piazza dei Miracoli and names its monuments as the cathedral, the leaning tower, the baptistery and the Camposanto.[1]

The Opera della Primaziale Pisana describes itself as the organisation set up to oversee the building of the square's monuments, whose charter covers protecting and promoting them; its site sells tickets and also names two museums, the Sinopie Museum and the Opera del Duomo Museum.[4] The guide to Pisa's Piazza del Duomo covers the monuments and how their tickets work, and the explainer on why the tower leans covers the tower's engineering history.

XTOUR's reading is that Pisa's listed sites are compact rather than numerous: a base there makes most sense when the square itself is the point of the trip. That is a planning judgement, not a measurement.

What is in Siena

Siena's listing is its historic centre. UNESCO's 1995 inscription decision describes Siena as an outstanding medieval city that has preserved its character and quality, with buildings designed to fit into the overall planned urban fabric and to form a whole with the surrounding cultural landscape.[5] In its entry on Siena's historic centre, Tuscany's tourism site names the Piazza del Campo, the Torre del Mangia, the Palazzo Pubblico, the cathedral and Santa Maria della Scala among the places to visit.[1]

XTOUR's reading is that Siena suits a stay built around a single medieval townscape rather than a list of separate museums.

The three side by side

Florence, Pisa and Siena compared by their listed sites
TownWorld Heritage listingSites XTOUR's sources name
FlorenceHistoric centre, 1982Cathedral, Santa Croce, San Miniato al Monte, Uffizi Gallery, Palazzo Pitti, Boboli Gardens
PisaPiazza del Duomo (Piazza dei Miracoli), 1987Cathedral, baptistery, leaning tower, Camposanto
SienaHistoric centre, 1995Piazza del Campo, Torre del Mangia, Palazzo Pubblico, cathedral, Santa Maria della Scala

In each town, not near it

XTOUR records each site under the town it is in. A visit to Pisa planned from Florence is still a visit to Pisa, and XTOUR will not list the leaning tower under Florence because a plan starts there. The same applies to Siena. Tuscany is a region, not a destination: Is Tuscany a city? explains how the region, its provinces and these towns relate, and the Italy travel guide covers bases beyond Tuscany.

What XTOUR does not tell you

XTOUR does not publish travel times, train or bus services between the three towns, opening hours, prices or booking rules. The Uffizi and the Opera della Primaziale Pisana publish their own visiting rules on their sites; XTOUR has not read an official visitor page for Siena's monuments.

Sources & references

Frequently asked questions

Good to know

Is the Leaning Tower in Florence?

No. The Opera della Primaziale Pisana, the body set up to oversee the building of the monuments in Pisa's Piazza del Duomo, names the tower as one of the square's four monuments with the cathedral, the baptistery and the Camposanto, and Pisa is a separate town from Florence.

Who sells tickets for the monuments in Pisa's Piazza del Duomo?

The Opera della Primaziale Pisana, the organisation set up to oversee the building of the square's monuments, sells them online on its own site, opapisa.it. XTOUR's guide to Pisa's Piazza del Duomo explains how the Opera's tickets for the Tower and the other monuments are organised.